Carys Reitman (Phillips) has been morbidly obsessed with death since her younger sister died years before. She goes to strangers' memorial services and funerals and is best friends with undertaker Shane (Masterson). While paying her respects to Anna, Carys manages to accidentally misappropriate the dead woman's engagement ring and then pretends to be a friend in order to return the ring to Anna's fiance Tyler (Somerhalder), which causes more problems. The contrivances become increasingly annoying as the film stumbles along.