Putch's loosely interconnected stories are set along the Lincoln highway in south-central Pennsylvania. In "Deer Hunters Wives," Civil War tour guide Mandy (Boltt) is obsessed with the story of a female civilian killed at the battle of Gettysburg. "What I Believe" has a man explaining to a Christian Scientist that he injured his back after being chased through the mountains by Bigfoot. And in "Original Bill," writer Bill (DeLuise) buys a farmhouse hoping for quiet and inspiration but discovers his Amish neighbor Martha (Delany) isn't what he expected.