When she was 12, Holly Grant asked Santa for a Christmas boyfriend and he promises her one--in 20 years. Now working for a nonprofit, Holly (Williams) is ticked at attorney Ryan (Muldoon), whom she's never met, when he misses an important appointment. When he turns up on her doorstep with a Christmas tree to make amends, Holly thinks he's someone else and he goes along with the charade so they can have a chance at romance. Her family thinks Holly's new guy is great but what will happen when the truth comes out? A Hallmark Channel original.