When ex-nun Christine Bennett (Ward) visits her cousin in a mental facility, she meets savant James Talley (Proval). He and his twin, Edward, have been separated for 30 years, ever since they were accused, but not convicted, of their mother's murder on Good Friday, 1974, and a judge sent them to separate hospitals. Christine becomes suspicious and teams up with handsome detective Jack Brooks (Weisser) to have the case re-opened. But someone is deadly serious about wanting Christine to mind her own business.