Style Over Substance
Reviewed by Sharkbait for Robots at 2009-03-06 20:44:40
It's obvious they started this movie with the visual ideas (as they state they did in the DVD extras). They came up with this world--which is absolutely, mind-bogglingly, beautifully rendered in the film--and then hung a paper-thin plot on it. The voice cast is pretty good (minus Halle Berry, who is just bland), but the visuals definitely stick with you longer than any of the story elements.
Disagree with the Hound on this one....excellent flick
Reviewed by KHL for Stay at 2008-10-15 12:23:04
This is a 'multiple viewings' movie; having only seen it once, I am already wanting to see it again to pick up what I missed the first time around. Beautifully, artfully directed story about characters who don't seem to have a grip on what their own reality is. Kind of like Shyamalan, it's hard to describe much else, except to say that it's a stellar cast, riveting performances and mesmerizing to watch.
This is good fun, if you can swallow its cartoonlike action sequences and shallow characters. It would be easy to scoff at how people are able to fall long distances and still survive, but if you can suspend judgement, it is possible to be entertained by this movie on the level that it asks you to be entertained.
The main reason I enjoyed this movie was to see the birth of Darth Vader. Again the choice of Hayden Christensen as the role of Anakin was not much to be enjoyed. Overall the movie was better than Ep1 and 2 and gave a convincing tie to the Classic Trilogy.
SWAoTC was a good movie. Much better than SWPM. I enjoyed it again, because of the back story of much loved characters. It is not as good as the Classic Trilogy, but a True Lucas/Star Wars fan should not discount the film entirely. Hayden Christensen is the absolute worst choice for Anakin Skywalker. Its sad Mr. Christensen is a pretty bad actor, even in other roles (the 2008 Jumper). I wish someone would invent a time machine, and go back and convince Lucas to recast Anakin. Oh well. :D
I've seen many Fan versions of SWI and they are better than Lucas' version. I liked the movie as it gives good back story to many characters that I loved in the Classic Trilogy. Jar Jar is not as bad as some people suggest, the voice is terrible, but the character is annoying at worst. I hope some one will do a Re-imagining of SWI someday.
Manic Musical Eye Candy
Reviewed by KHL for Moulin Rouge at 2008-03-24 17:20:18
Seeing this in the theater when it was released, there was a palpable air of 'what the...?'. A raucous, raunchy musical romp through the last year of the century in Paris. If you can get beyond the fact that you'll hear everything from Nirvana to Elton John to Air Supply (gasp!), to Wings in the cleverly constructed soundtrack, then you're fine! The more I've viewed it since that first showing, the more I enjoy it. There's so much kinetic imagery that it's hard to take it all in in one sitting. McGregor and Kidman are great (and sound pretty good too) as doomed lovers, but Broadbent and Roxburgh, as the 'ringleader' of the Moulin Rouge and the 'evil Duke' are hysterical and nearly steal the show (the best number has to be their strange and comedically menacing cover of 'Like a Virgin' by Madonna). Costumes are fantastic and while about 20 minutes could probably have been cut, it still makes for an entertaining time.
Jar Jar Binks. Need I write more? After waiting so many years for more installments in the "Star Wars" series, fans are disappointed with a childlike, naive, lame story, lame characters, lame dialogue. This film contains tons of positive elements and much potential, but is bad on so many other levels it's ridiculous. Couldn't Lucas surround himself with staff that would force him to realize what parts sucked? I don't get it. Can't wait for someone to remake this film.
Newspaper article from: Entertainment Newsweekly; 3/12/2010; 544 words...Media and Lionsgate, is scheduled for release in 2011. The film's stars include Gina Carano, Michael Douglas, EwanMcGregor and Channing Tatum. "Over 40 films have been made at Garson; several are Academy Award winners," said Paula Amanda...
Newspaper article from: Entertainment Newsweekly; 11/28/2008; 1128+ words...Summit Entertainment's Never Back Down with Sean Farris; in Michael Bay's futuristic action film The Island, with EwanMcGregor and Scarlett Johansson; the thriller Constantine, with Keanu Reeves; and he was part of the ensemble cast in the...
Newspaper article from: Contemporary Theatre, Film and Television; 1/1/2005; 3489+ words...MTV Movie awards, best female performance and (with EwanMcGregor) best musical sequence, Academy Award nomination...Award nominations, best musical sequence and (with EwanMcGregor) best kiss, and Screen Actors Guild Award nomination...
Newspaper article from: Contemporary Theatre, Film and Television; 1/1/2005; 2118+ words...a crossover role in a feature film, 1998, all for My Best Friend's Wedding; MTV Movie Award nomination (with EwanMcGregor), best dance sequence, 1997, for A Life Less Ordinary; Golden Globe Award nomination, best performance by an...
Newspaper article from: Contemporary Theatre, Film and Television; 1/1/2004; 1843+ wordsMcGREGOR, Ewan 1971 – PERSONAL First name is pronounced "You – in"; full name, Ewan Gordon McGregor; born March 31, 1971, in Crieff, Perth, Scotland; son of James...